Best credit cards with car rental insurance: Protect yourself and earn miles, points or cash back

Chase Sapphire Preferred Card

The Chase Sapphire Preferred offers excellent travel protections, including primary car rental insurance that covers damage due to theft or collision to your rental car, when you pay for the rental with your card. This is great for personal trips, since many cards restrict the primary insurance to business trips. You also earn 2x Chase Ultimate Rewards points on travel and dining and there are no foreign transaction fees.

We recommend the Chase Sapphire Preferred as a first credit card for beginners to the miles-and-points hobby. And it’s our top pick to use for car rentals if you aren’t interested in a premium card like the Chase Sapphire Reserve. When you sign up and are approved, you’ll earn 60,000 Chase Ultimate Rewards points after spending $4,000 on purchases in the first three months of opening your account.

You can redeem the sign-up bonus for $600 in cash back or $750 in travel booked through the Chase travel portal. You will get potentially more value if you transfer points directly to airline and hotel partners like Hyatt.

You’ll also get:

• 2x Chase Ultimate Rewards points per $1 spent on travel and dining worldwide
  
• 1x Chase Ultimate Rewards point per $1 spent on all other purchase
• Trip delay reimbursement – Get up to $500 back per ticket when your trip is delayed more than 12 hours

The card has a $95 annual fee. Here’s our review of the Chase Sapphire Preferred.

United℠ Explorer Card

Ink Business Preferred Credit Card

The Chase Ink Business Preferred earns Chase Ultimate Rewards points, which are our favorite flexible points. You’ll also get primary car rental coverage when renting a car for business purposes.

The Ink Business Preferred card comes with a sign-up bonus of 100,000 Chase Ultimate Rewards points after you spend $15,000 on purchases in the first three months from account opening.

That’s enough for:

• $1,250 in travel by booking airfare, hotel stays or car rentals through Chase’s travel portal (with no blackout dates)
• Potentially even more value by transferring points directly to airline and hotel partners, like Hyatt, Southwest or United Airlines

With the Ink Business Preferred, you also get:

• 3x Chase Ultimate Rewards points for every $1 spent on travel, shipping purchases, internet, cable and phone services, advertising purchases made with social media sites and search engines (up to a maximum of $150,000 in combined purchases per account anniversary year)
• 1x Chase Ultimate Rewards points on all other purchases
• Up to $600 in cellphone insurance when you pay your phone bill with the card

The card’s $95 annual fee is not waived the first year. And the cellphone insurance perk actually works.

This is a small-business card but you might qualify without realizing it. Check our step-by-step guide to completing a Chase business-card application.

This card comes under the Chase’s 5/24 rule. You’ll find our review of the Chase Ink Business Preferred here.

Ink Business Cash Credit Card

The Chase Ink Business Cash card comes with primary rental car insurance coverage when used for renting a car for business purposes and the highest-ever Ink Business Cash welcome bonus — $500 cash back (50,000 Chase Ultimate Rewards points) after spending $3,000 on purchases in the first three months of account opening. It’s an awesome deal and the card has no annual fee.

The Ink Business Cash also comes with:

• 5% cash back (5x Chase Ultimate Rewards points) on the first $25,000 spent in combined purchases at office supply stores and on phone, internet and cable TV services each account anniversary year
• 2% cash back (2x Chase Ultimate Rewards points) on the first $25,000 spent in combined purchases at gas stations and restaurants each account anniversary year
• 1% cash back (1x Chase Ultimate Rewards point) on all other purchases

The primary car rental insurance is for rentals for business purposes and you have to pay with your Chase Ink Business Cash card. It provides only secondary coverage when renting for personal use. I’ve kept this card in my wallet for years because it has no annual fee. And I always use it to earn 5% cash back (5x points) at Staples when shopping for my vacation rental business. Bonus points like that really add up. Here’s our review.

Top American Express cards

Most American Express cards include secondary rental car coverage, but all Amex cards offer primary car rental coverage for a small additional fee, which can definitely be worth it.

You can enroll and see more details about the American Express Premium Car Rental Protection program online. What makes this program unique is that you pay ~$25 (~$18 for California residents and ~$15 for Florida residents) per rental for up to 42 consecutive rental days (30 consecutive rental days for Washington State cardholders).

Most car rental companies charge this same price daily. The American Express Premium Car Rental Protection program does not, however, cover rentals in Australia, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Jamaica and New Zealand.

You can read more about the best American Express card offers. Applying for Amex small-business cards will not hurt your chances for card approvals with Chase (if you’ve applied for many new cards recently) because Amex small-business cards do not appear on your personal credit report.

So if you qualify, applying for an Amex small-business card can be a great way to earn bonuses for free travel.

Understanding primary vs. secondary car rental coverage

One of the biggest causes for confusion with credit cards is understanding how the popular “car rental insurance” perk actually works. It’s important to understand the difference between primary and secondary coverage. 

Say you charge a car rental to a credit card that offers secondary car rental insurance and decline the collision damage waiver (CDW) offered by the car rental agency. Lots of folks do this in order to save money, because the CDW can get pricey (it isn’t uncommon for it to double the cost of your rental).

If you have a car insurance policy in the U.S. and you get in an accident in the U.S., the secondary car rental credit card insurance will only cover what’s left over after you file a claim with your primary car insurance provider. You will still be responsible for the deductible through your insurance company and you will need to report the accident to them, which can lead to an increase in your premium. The secondary insurance on your credit card also would not cover damage to the other car, any property damage or injuries to you or others.

If you don’t have a car insurance policy in the U.S., secondary rental car insurance on a credit card will work as primary rental car insurance and will usually pay for physical damage to the car and damage due to theft, loss-of-use charges and towing charges for the rental car. You’d still liable for damages to other property and persons.

Similarly, outside the U.S. most secondary credit card rental car insurance will actually be primary rental car insurance and will pay for physical damage to the car and damage due to theft, loss-of-use charges and towing charges for the rental car. You will still be liable for damage to other property and persons.

By comparison, if you charge the rental to a credit card offering primary car rental coverage and decline the collision damage waiver offered by the car rental agency, the credit card insurance will usually pick up the bill for physical damage and damage due to theft, loss-of-use charges, and towing for the rental car if you get into an accident (up to the coverage limit) without requiring you to file a claim with your personal car insurance company.

That said, like secondary car rental insurance, the primary car rental insurance will not cover damage to the other car, any property damaged, and injuries to you or others. And you are still liable for those damages. Your personal car insurance policy may cover those claims.

Using a card that offers primary car rental insurance when you decline the collision damage waiver through the car rental agency can end up saving you a lot if something happens.  Most credit cards offer secondary rental car insurance coverage, but a handful offer primary rental car insurance coverage.