8 Reasons Why You Should Choose the AMEX Starwood Over the Chase Marriott Card

Disclosure: We get a commission for links on the blog. You don’t have to use our links, but we’re very grateful when you do. American Express, Barclaycard, Capital One, Chase, and US Bank are Million Mile Secrets advertising partners. Opinions expressed here are the author's alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or endorsed by our partners. Here’s our Advertiser Disclosure.

Update:   One or more card offers in this post are no longer available.  Check our Hot Deals for the latest offers. 

If you’re looking to earn the most points for free stays at Marriott, Starwood, and Ritz-Carlton hotels, you’ll want to consider the limited time AMEX Starwood offer.  It’s the biggest bonus I’ve seen for the personal and small business cards!

Remember, Marriott, Ritz-Carlton, and Starwood are now one company.  But the hotel chains still have separate co-branded credit cards.  And the current sign-up bonuses for each of the hotel cards are very different!

For example, the current AMEX Starwood card sign-up bonus is a total of 35,000 Starwood points after meeting tiered minimum spending requirements.  This can get you 3 free nights at the Waikoloa Beach Marriott Resort & Spa in Hawaii.  But the sign-up bonus with the Marriott Rewards® Premier Credit Card would only get you 2 free nights.

AMEX Starwood Versus Chase Marriott

You’ll Get the Most Big Travel at Marriott, Starwood, or Ritz-Carlton Hotels With the Limited Time AMEX Starwood Sign-Up Bonus. It Can Get You 3 Free Nights at the Waikoloa Beach Marriott Resort & Spa in Hawaii

I’ll review the current AMEX and Marriott card offers and share 8 pros of the AMEX Starwood card.

AMEX Starwood Versus Chase Marriott

Here’s a review of the current offers for the AMEX Starwood and Chase Marriott personal and small business cards.

1.   AMEX Starwood

Link:   Starwood Preferred Guest® Credit Card from American Express 

Link:   Starwood Preferred Guest® Business Credit Card from American Express

Link:   Limited Time:   Best-Ever 35,000 Points Sign-Up Bonus With AMEX Starwood Cards Returns!

With the personal AMEX Starwood card, you’ll earn 25,000 Starwood points after spending $3,000 on purchases within the first 3 months of account opening.  And 10,000 more Starwood points for spending another $2,000 on purchases within the first 6 months.

And with the AMEX Starwood small business card, you’ll earn 25,000 Starwood points after spending $5,000 on purchases within the first 3 months of account opening.  And 10,000 more Starwood points for spending another $3,000 on purchases within the first 6 months.

With either offer, you’ll earn a total of 35,000 Starwood points after meeting the tiered minimum spending requirements!

AMEX Starwood Versus Chase Marriott

You’ll Earn a Total of 35,000 Starwood Points With the Personal or Small Business Version of the AMEX Starwood Card

You’ll also get:

The $95 annual fee is waived for the first year on both cards.

Note:   You’re only eligible to earn AMEX sign-up bonuses once per card per lifetime.

Keep in mind the personal and small business versions are different card products.  So if you have the AMEX Starwood personal card, you can still get the small business version.  And vice versa.

2.   Chase Marriott

Link:   Marriott Rewards® Premier Credit Card

Link:   Marriott Rewards Premier Business Credit Card

When you sign-up for the Chase Marriott Premier Rewards card or Marriott Rewards Premier Business Credit Card and spend $3,000 on purchases within the first 3 months of opening your account, you’ll earn 80,000 Marriott points.

Other perks of this card include:

  • 1 free night in a Marriott Category 1 to 5 location on your card anniversary
  • 5 Marriott points per $1 spent at MarriottRitz-Carlton, and Starwood hotels
  • 2 Marriott points per $1 at restaurants, on car rentals, and airline tickets purchased directly from the airline
  • 2 Marriott points per $1 at office supply stores and for internet, cable and phone service purchases (only with the small business version)
  • 1 Marriott point per $1 spent on all other purchases
  • No foreign transaction fees
  • 15 nights credit towards elite status (so you get Marriott Silver status)
  • Visa Signature discounts

And with the personal version, you’ll earn an additional 7,500 bonus Marriott points when you add an authorized user who makes a purchase within the first 3 months of opening your account.

The $85 annual fee for the personal card and $99 annual fee for the small business version are NOT waived for the first year.

Note:   You are NOT eligible to receive a new Chase cardmember sign-up bonus if you’ve received a bonus on the same card in the past 24 months.

8 Pros of Getting the AMEX Starwood Card

1.   Sign-Up Bonus and Minimum Spending Points Are Worth More

With the AMEX Starwood cards, you can earn a total of 35,000 Starwood points with the sign-up bonus plus at least 5,000 Starwood points from meeting the tiered minimum spending requirement.

In total, you’ll have at least 40,000 Starwood points, which you can instantly convert to 120,000 Marriott or Ritz-Carlton points (at a 1:3 ratio).

That’s enough for 2 free nights at luxurious hotels like The Ritz-Carlton, San Juan.

AMEX Starwood Versus Chase Marriott

The AMEX Starwood Sign-Up Bonus and Points From Minimum Spending Can Get You 2 Free Nights at The Ritz-Carlton, San Juan in Puerto Rico

This compares to 90,500 Marriott points you’ll earn with the sign-up bonus, points from minimum spending, and bonus from adding an authorized user with the Chase Marriott personal card.  With the 3:1 transfer ratio, this converts to ~30,000 Starwood points.

So getting the AMEX Starwood card means you’ll have ~10,000 more Starwood points or 29,500 more Marriott points.

That’s a substantial difference!  Because you can redeem the extra points for more free nights!

2.   Annual Fee Is Waived the First Year

The AMEX Starwood cards have a $95 annual fee, which is waived for the first year.

The annual fees are NOT waived on the Chase Marriott cards.

So you can try out the AMEX Starwood card for ~10 months to see if you like the perks.  Then, decide if it’s worth keeping.

I think the AMEX Starwood card is worth keeping after the first year.  Especially if you value the perks of the cards, like the 2 stay credits or 5 night credits toward Starwood elite status, or earning Starwood points to transfer to ~30 airline partners.

After you’ve had the card for awhile, you can call AMEX and ask for a retention offer.  For example, team member Keith called and received 3,000 bonus Starwood points for keeping his AMEX Starwood card open for another year.

3.   Earn More Points on Everyday Spending With the AMEX Starwood Card

You can earn more Starwood, Marriott, or Ritz-Carlton points by using the AMEX Starwood card for everyday purchases.

Because you’ll earn 1 Starwood point per $1 you spend.  Then, you can convert 1 Starwood point you earn to 3 Marriott points.

With the Chase Marriott card, you only earn 1 or 2 Marriott points per $1 spent for most purchases.

AMEX Starwood Versus Chase Marriott

Pay for Purchases With Your AMEX Starwood Card and You’ll Earn More Starwood Points Than If You Used the Chase Marriott Card

You’ll also earn more points by using the AMEX Starwood card to pay for stays at Marriott, Ritz-Carlton, and Starwood hotels.

With the 1:3 transfer ratio, you’ll essentially earn 6 Marriott or Ritz-Carlton points per $1 spent on Marriott or Ritz-Carlton stays when you use your AMEX Starwood card.

This is better than the 5 Marriott or Ritz-Carlton points you’ll earn using the Chase Marriott card!

And AMEX sometimes has promotions to earn bonus Starwood points after meeting spending requirements.

4.   Transfer Starwood Points to Airlines

Starwood points are extremely valuable because you can redeem them for more than just free hotel nights.

For example, you can transfer points directly to airline partners like American Airlines, Alaska Airlines, Emirates, and more.  Plus, you get 5,000 bonus miles when you transfer 20,000 Starwood points to airline partners.

AMEX Starwood Versus Chase Marriott

Save Up Starwood Points to Transfer to Airline Partners and You Can Book a Cathay Pacific First Class Flight!

Because Starwood points and Marriott points are interchangeable, it’s possible to convert Marriott points to Starwood points and then transfer to airline partners as well.

But it’s an extra step some folks might not want to deal with.  So earning Starwood points directly with the AMEX Starwood card makes it easier.

5.   AMEX Starwood Small Business Card Won’t Appear on Your Credit Report

If you get the AMEX Starwood small business card, it will NOT appear on your personal credit report.

This is good news for folks who are looking to avoid Chase card application limits.  Because Chase won’t approve you for most cards if you’ve opened ~5 or more credit cards (from any bank) in the past 24 months (excluding certain business cards).

AMEX Starwood Versus Chase Marriott

Get the AMEX Starwood Small Business Card and Enjoy Big Travel at Hotels Like the St. Regis Bali! And You Don’t Have to Worry About the Card Showing Up on Your Personal Credit Report!

If you don’t have a business, check out these 7 quick small business ideas, which don’t require a significant upfront investment and could qualify you for a small business card.

And keep in mind there are no strict income requirements for an AMEX small business card.  This means the AMEX Starwood small business card can be relatively easy to get!

6.   Save Money With AMEX Offers

With the AMEX Starwood card, you can use AMEX Offers to save money on purchases you may already be planning.

Recent AMEX offers have included:

  • $5 back when you purchase a $75+ Hilton gift card through AMEX
  • $35 back when you spend $175+ at Hampton or Hilton Garden Inn
  • $50 back on a $200+ purchase online at Neiman Marcus
AMEX Starwood Versus Chase Marriott

Saving Money With AMEX Offers Is a Great Perk of the AMEX Starwood Card

AMEX is always updating their offers.  You just have to register your card before the purchase, so you can get the savings!

7.   Relatively Easier to Get AMEX Starwood Card

Folks impacted by Chase’s stricter application rules might not get approved for the Chase Marriott card.

Because if you’ve opened ~5 or more credit cards (from any bank) in the past 24 months (excluding certain business cards), it’s unlikely you’ll be approved for most Chase cards.

AMEX Starwood Versus Chase Marriott

If You Have Lots of Recent Credit Cards, It’s Unlikely You’ll Get Approved for the Chase Marriott Card

I’ve heard from some folks that Chase Marriott small business card is NOT impacted by the Chase rule.  But I can’t say for certain.

With the tougher Chase rules, getting the AMEX Starwood card might be the only way for folks to quickly boost their Marriott or Starwood points balances.

Even if you don’t have a lot of recent credit cards, I probably wouldn’t recommend getting the Chase Marriott card first.  Because Chase has several other fantastic travel credit cards with more valuable sign-up bonuses.

8.   Last Time We’ll See 35,000 Starwood Points?

This is only the 2nd time I’ve seen the AMEX Starwood card have a 35,000 Starwood point sign-up bonus.  And I have a hunch it might be the last time.

I said the AMEX Starwood card could possibly be discontinued in the future following the Starwood and Marriott merger.  This might not happen until 2018 when Marriott and Starwood are expected to merge loyalty programs.

So given Starwood points are hard to earn and there’s potential for the card to go away, it’s another reason to choose the AMEX Starwood cards.

Bottom Line

Folks looking to get the most Big Travel at Marriott, Starwood, and Ritz-Carlton hotels can do well with the AMEX Starwood personal and small business cards.

Because with the limited time offer, you can earn a total of 35,000 Starwood points after meeting tiered minimum spending requirements.  With the points from the spending requirement, you’ll have at least 40,000 Starwood points.

And you can transfer Starwood points to Marriott or Ritz-Carlton points at a 1:3 ratio.  So 40,000 Starwood points gets you 120,000 Starwood or Ritz-Carlton points.  That’s more than you can earn with the Chase Marriott sign-up bonus.  This means more free nights with the AMEX Starwood card!

And unlike the Chase Marriott card, the annual fee on the AMEX Starwood card is waived the first year.  Plus, you can earn more points on everyday purchases.

What’s your favorite AMEX Starwood card perk?

* If you liked this post, why don’t you join the 25,000+ readers who have signed-up to receive free blog posts via email (only 1 email per day!) or in an RSS reader …because then you’ll never miss another update!

Editorial Disclaimer: Neither the responses below nor the editorial content on this page are provided or commissioned by the bank advertisers, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertisers. Opinions expressed here are the author’s alone, not those of the bank advertisers. It is not the bank advertisers’ responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

13 responses to “8 Reasons Why You Should Choose the AMEX Starwood Over the Chase Marriott Card

  1. What card would you recommend for if I am going to be spending about 8k in the next three months considering I have the following: Chase Sapphire Reserve (I usually do all my spending on this card), Southwest persona/business (already earned companion pass spending reqs), and United Mileage plus (probably will be closing soon). I am considering between the Chase Ink (which I suppose I should wait til next month for the 100k offer) or this SPG card. I don’t have any hotel credit card yet and was trying to find one that offered automatic tiered membership bonus but haven’t seen anything like that. You’re input would be greatly appreciated thank you in advance!!!

    • The AMEX Starwood small business card might be a good pick. It requires $8,000 in spending to get the total sign-up bonus. And it won’t show up on your personal credit report, which means it won’t count toward the Chase “5/24” limit. So you can still get the Chase Ink Business Preferred in the future when the sign-up bonus increases in-branch.

      • If I have both of them, which one should I keep if I have to keep one at the end of the year? With business you have the added advantage of access to Sheraton Lounges but then if you routinely spend a lot on it for a long period of time, you really won’t have your credit reflecting that since business cards don’t appear on it – is that something one should worry about even?

  2. Glad I saw this article. After picking up the CSR last month, I’m at 5/24 and was planning to wait a few months (to get under 4/24) before applying for the Marriott Visa. I’m not a fan of Starwood hotel properties (compared to Hilton, Marriott, Hyatt, etc.) and wouldn’t have considered the SPG Amex. But I wasn’t aware of the 3:1 conversion ratio, which obviously makes the (points) math look a lot better. So something to really think about!

    • Greetings Luke,
      Not a fan of Starwood? Westin and W properties are very likable!! I would enjoy hearing your thoughts.

      • Good point. It’s probably an outdated bias, but my impression has been that the typical Hilton/Doubletree or Hyatt is/was nicer than a typical Sheraton. Wife and I used the Hyatt Visa card to get free nights at the Park Hyatt Sydney, which was a phenomenal property/location (so I’m probably spoiled now). I’m sure they are nice, but don’t recall ever staying at a Westin or W, so perhaps getting an SPG Amex will provide the opportunity to try them out.

    • I have the card and have never stayed at a property before! I’m more of a Marriott and Hyatt person so have transferred my points to Marriott to qualify for the SW companion pass. I have a new puppy so hoping to check out Aloft properties which are pet friendly and don’t charge an additional fee.

  3. I’ve taken advantage of the AMEX offers they do change so you have to check back periodically.

  4. you forget that one big detail in comparing…AMEX sucks.
    With the one bonus per lifetime rule most people don’t qualify for anything from the spg card. They are not accepted at many stores and merchants hate their higher processing fees. They won’t match offers, if you find a better one after applying. They treat customers like a number and will launch a financial revue and demand to see tax records and other documents if your account looks the least bit suspicious (to them)…other than the transfer rate to Marriott there is nothing good about this card. no elite status, no free annual night, few bonus catagories…..I’m not saying SPG points are bad, but once you get some with this card, throw the amex in the trash.

  5. Hello – would you recommend that I get the AMEX Starwood Business card again if I have already received the bonus for this card (as well as the non-business version)? I am Plat at SPG and so plan to re-qualify this year, hence the stays will continue to rack up points with the card. Thanks.

    • Hi Gymrat – You won’t get the bonus if you’ve had the card before, so I wouldn’t get it for the bonus. You do get 5 nights and 2 stays with each version of the card, so could help with requalifying for status.

  6. I was just approved for the card. I used your link, so hopefully you will get the commission. Thanks for posting- I am brand new to this, but am enjoying your blog immensely and can’t wait for some cheap travel!