Marriott or Starwood: Which Is a Better Deal to Book With Points?

Signing up for credit cards through partner links earns us a commission. Terms apply to the offers listed on this page. Here’s our full advertising policy: How we make money.

Update: One or more card offers in this post are no longer available. Check our Hot Deals for the latest offers.

When Marriott acquired Starwood, it created lots of opportunities for folks to take advantage of both programs.  But it also made finding the best deal a little more confusing.

Marriott Or Starwood Which Is A Better Deal To Book With Points
The Marriott-Starwood Merger Opened Sweet Deals Like Being Able to Stay at the Le Meridien Pyramids Hotel & Spa for Only 6,000 Marriott Points on Weekend Nights

Million Mile Secret Agent Steve commented:

With the Marriott-Starwood merger which would be better – using 10,000 Starwood points for a hotel or 25,000 Marriott points for a hotel in the same area?

Let’s take a look at these hotels.  And figure out how to find the best deal for you.

Not All Hotel Points Are Created Equal

Not all points have the same value.  Because every hotel chain has a different award chart.  For example, Hyatt only charges 30,000 Hyatt points for their top-tier hotels.  But Hilton requires a whopping 95,000 Hilton points to book their most expensive hotels!

When you’re deciding which hotel to book make sure you’re comparing apples to apples.

Since the Marriott-Starwood merger, you can transfer Marriott points to Starwood at a 3:1 ratio.  So 10,000 Starwood points are worth 30,000 Marriott points.  That makes the Marriott hotel a better deal for only 25,000 points, right?

Not so fast!  If you only have a small number of points left in your account, there usually isn’t much you can do with them.  And there are other things to consider when deciding which hotel is the best deal.

What Can You Do With the Extra Points?

You can only transfer points between Marriott and Starwood in 1,000-point increments.  So, unless Steve has an extra 1,000 Marriott points in his account, he would have to transfer 9,000 Starwood points for his Marriott stay (9,000 Starwood points X 3 = 27,000 Marriott points).

Marriott Or Starwood Which Is A Better Deal To Book With Points
You Can Link Your Starwood & Marriott Accounts to Transfer Points Between Accounts

The points difference between the hotels is 1,000 to 2,000 Starwood points.  With 2,000 Starwood points, you could book a weekend night at a Category 1 hotel.  But Starwood Category 1 hotels are few and far between.  So it might not be as useful as it seems.

Note:   Marriott has been running a lot of social media promotions recently.  You can easily earn ~1,000 Marriott points just by linking your social media accounts.

Check Hotel Reviews and Consider Other Costs

Other factors can have a much bigger impact on the quality of your trip than the amount of points you spend.

1.   Check TripAdvisor Reviews

When the points difference between 2 hotels is minimal, check TripAdvisor and other sites to compare reviews.  What others say about a hotel is sometimes more important to look at than the rating.  Because what one person values might be very different from what you value.

Marriott Or Starwood Which Is A Better Deal To Book With Points
Compare Hotels on TripAdvisor Based on What Folks Are Saying – NOT Just the Rating

If folks on TripAdvisor are complaining about the small portion sizes at the hotel restaurant is that important to you?  Not if you don’t plan on eating there or are a light eater. 😉  But if folks are complaining about the staff or poor housekeeping service, that probably will impact your decision.

2.   Does the Hotel Have Freebies?

Consider any freebies or perks you’ll get.

If you have elite status, what does it get you?  Does either hotel have an executive lounge?  If it’s a Marriott hotel, Gold elite status will get you lounge access.  But this is not the case with Starwood hotels!

Does the hotel offer free breakfast, or appetizers and drinks in the evening, regardless of elite status?  That alone would be worth more than 1,000 Starwood points!  And could save you a lot of money, especially on longer stays.

Are you traveling with family?  Does the hotel have a pool, fitness center, or other amenity that would make your stay more fun or comfortable?

Marriott Or Starwood Which Is A Better Deal To Book With Points
Some Hotel Amenities, Like a Pool, Are Worth More to Some Folks

Does either hotel offer complimentary shuttle service?  Lots of small factors could have a big impact on the quality of your stay!

3. Hidden Fees & Extra Costs

It’s a bummer to use points for what you thought was a free night, only to be hit with fees you weren’t expecting.  Some hotels will charge extra fees even for stays booked with points.

So check if the hotel charges for parking.  And you’ll want to find out if the location adds a resort fee.

It doesn’t make sense to save a few points only to discover lots of extra fees!

Are You Trying to Earn Elite Status?

Starwood & Marriott award stays both earn elite status credit.  You will earn Marriott Gold elite status after 50 nights.  BUT you’ll earn Starwood Gold elite status after only 10 stays or 25 nights!

Marriott Or Starwood Which Is A Better Deal To Book With Points
Treat Yourself to Gold Elite Status With Starwood After Only 10 Stays

So if you’re trying to earn Gold elite status, Starwood is the faster option.  Plus your status will instantly match with Marriott!

Can You Book A PointSavers Award or Other Discounted Rate?

Some Marriott hotels offer PointSavers awards, which means you can book a hotel for 1 Category less than normal.  So you could book a Category 5 at the Category 4 rate of 20,000 Marriott points per night (instead of 25,000).  And Starwood has discounted weekend awards for Category 1 & Category 2 hotels.

If you have a longer stay planned, both Marriott & Starwood will give you the 5th night free on award stays!  And if you book 10 award nights, you’ll get both the 5th & 10th nights free!

Note:   The Starwood 5th night free benefit on award stays does NOT apply to Category 1 or Category 2 hotels.

Stock up on Marriott or Starwood Points!

Earning the sign-up bonus on one of the Marriott or Starwood credit cards is the easiest way to get more points.  The current bonuses are:

  Note:   There is also a 120,000 Marriott point offer for the Marriott personal card.  But it is a little different than a traditional sign-up bonus.  So make sure it’s the best deal for your situation before being tempted by the big number.

You can also transfer Chase Ultimate Rewards points to Marriott at a 1:1 ratio.  And AMEX Membership Rewards points transfer to Starwood at a 3:1 ratio.  But I don’t recommend this because it’s usually not the best deal.

Bottom Line

The Marriott-Starwood merger gives folks plenty to think about when it comes to booking award stays.  Because there are lots of opportunities for great deals.  And you can move your points in ways you couldn’t before.

When the points difference between a Starwood or Marriott hotel isn’t significant, consider:

I hope this helps!  Have fun on your trip, Steve!

Editorial Note: We're the Million Mile Secrets team. And we're proud of our content, opinions and analysis, and of our reader's comments. These haven’t been reviewed, approved or endorsed by any of the airlines, hotels, or credit card issuers which we often write about. And that’s just how we like it! :)

Join the Discussion!

Comments are closed.