Is Uber Charging Riders More & Paying Drivers Less?

Signing up for credit cards through partner links earns us a commission. Terms apply to the offers listed on this page. Here’s our full advertising policy: How we make money.

In recent months, Uber switched their method for pricing rides.

In the past, riders would receive a price estimate for a ride.  But the fare you paid at the end was determined based on the exact time and mileage of your ride.  And the Uber driver would receive a percentage of this final fare.

Now, instead of an estimate, Uber provides a guaranteed price for your ride upfront.  But The Ride Share Guy notes this new method might be causing discrepancies for both riders and drivers.

I’ll explain what’s going on with Uber’s upfront fares.

What’s the Deal With Uber Upfront Fares?

In the US and India, Uber now provides riders with a guaranteed price before requesting a ride.

For example, I searched a sample UberX fare from Central Park to the Park Hyatt New York.  Before requesting the ride, Uber guarantees the fare will be $10.52.

The guaranteed Uber fare is the sum of these amounts:

• Base fare
• Estimated per minute charge
• Estimated per mile charge
• Tolls (if applicable)

The per minute and mile estimates can vary depending if Uber is in strong demand in a certain area.

With this pricing model, Uber is essentially guessing at the time and distance for your ride.  If your driver makes a wrong turn or there’s heavy traffic, your fare will NOT increase.

But it’s possible your ride can take less time than Uber estimated.  Or your driver might find a quicker route.  In this case, your fare will NOT decrease.

In the end, you’ll simply pay the guaranteed fare you saw before requesting the ride, regardless of the actual time and mileage.  Of course, this assumes you only travel between the origin and requested destination.

Personally, I like this method.  Because the upfront price gives you the choice to explore alternatives, like a taxi, before requesting an Uber ride.

Potential Rider & Driver Discrepancies With Upfront Fares

The issue with the new fare method is the difference between what the rider is charged and the payout the driver receives.

Based on examples from The Ride Share Guy, it appears Uber is charging riders based on the guaranteed fare.  But then Uber pays the driver based on the actual time and distance for the ride.

For example, UberX drivers in San Francisco receive 80% of the the total fare minus a $1.55 booking fee.

So if Uber calculates a total driver fare of $10 based on the time and distance of a ride, a driver would receive a payout of ~$6.45 (80% of ($10 – $1.55 booking fee)).

But what if the rider paid more than $10 based on the upfront guaranteed fare?  Can Uber use 2 different fare calculations for riders and drivers?

I looked at the Uber driver website, which appears to have contradictory information.

For example, one page says the fare shown in the Uber driver’s app is the amount charged to the rider.

But a different page says the fare the driver sees in the app may NOT be the exact fare paid by the rider.

Uber hasn’t provided an official explanation on the fare discrepancies.  But I’m optimistic this could just be a temporary situation given Uber recently changed the pricing model.

I’m hopeful that Uber will continue to pay drivers based on a percentage of the actual fare paid by a rider.

What Can You Do as an Uber Rider?

Uber riders and drivers can wait until the end of a ride to confirm the upfront guaranteed rider fare matches the fare shown on the driver’s app.

Some folks say the driver app does not always instantly show the fare at the end of a ride.  But drivers can politely ask the rider for the upfront rate they received before requesting the ride.  Then, the driver can compare the fares at a later time.

The fare issue seems to be more impactful for drivers.  Because they might not be getting a payout based on the actual fare a rider is paying.

If you don’t like Uber’s new pricing system and the potential discrepancies, you can always use alternatives like Lyft or a taxi.

But I still think Uber is a convenient service.  In my experience, Uber drivers are very friendly and their cars tend to be cleaner than taxis.  

Bottom Line

With Uber’s new pricing model, there are fare discrepancies for riders and drivers.

Riders pay a guaranteed fare based on an upfront estimate, which doesn’t change, even if there’s traffic or you take a longer route.

But drivers are receiving a payout based on the actual time and distance of a trip, which might be less than what the rider paid.  This means Uber is taking a larger percentage of the fare.

Are you an Uber rider or driver?  I’d like to hear your experience regarding any fare discrepancies in the comments!