Some Rental Car Companies Charge an Extra $15 per Toll!

Signing up for credit cards through partner links earns us a commission. Terms apply to the offers listed on this page. Here’s our full advertising policy: How we make money.

Via the Washington Post, some rental car agencies have been charging very high fees for using their transponders, up to $15 per toll!

Some Rental Car Companies Charge An Extra 15 Per Toll
Enterprise and Dollar Rent a Car Are Being Sued for Charging Customers an Extra ~$15 per Toll

I’ll tell you how to avoid these fees and save money while renting a car.

How Rental Car Agencies Turn a Vehicle Into a “Fee-hicle”!

According to the Washington Post article, there is a lawsuit against Dollar Rent a Car because of “false and inflated administrative fees.”  Mentioned specifically, a couple went through 4 toll booths on the North Texas Highway that should have cost ~$5 each.

Instead they received a bill from Dollar Rent a Car charging them an additional $15 per toll.  Their total bill was ~$65 for what should have cost ~$20!

Some Rental Car Companies Charge An Extra 15 Per Toll
Some Rental Car Companies Charge Exorbitant Fees per Toll and for Using Their Transponder Device

And Business Week reports that Hertz reached an $11 million dollar settlement for a class-action lawsuit.  Hertz was hiding fees they charged customers each day they rented a car that had a transponder in it, even if they didn’t use it.

Many rental car companies charge ~$10 per day for you to carry their transponder.  And that doesn’t include the fees you’ll pay per toll.  And according to the article, that fee could be as high as ~$20 per day in New York City.

And you pay the charge for EVERY day you rent the car, even if you don’t pay a toll on certain days!

3 Ways to Protect Yourself From the Fees

Is cash the best option?  Should you avoid toll roads?  I’ll explain, you decide!

1 – Avoid Toll Roads

Tell the rental car agency that you do NOT want to rent their transponder.  Then set the car’s GPS to skip toll roads.  Your trip might take a bit longer if the free road is further away or has more traffic, but you’ll save money.

Or you can use an app on your phone such as Google Maps.  Set “Route Options” to avoid tolls.

Some Rental Car Companies Charge An Extra 15 Per Toll
You Can Get Directions That Specifically Avoid Toll Roads Where Possible

In some cases, your trip will take longer because of the greater distance or traffic on non-toll roads.

For instance, you might choose to save money while visiting New York City by staying in a hotel in Queens.  Your trip to the Bronx Zoo could take up to ~30 minutes longer (depending on traffic, etc.) if you avoid toll roads.

So do what makes sense for you.  And put a price on your time!

2 – BYOT – Bring Your Own Transponder!

When you’ll be driving within states that use the same transponder as you already own, bring it!  And tell the rental car agency you do NOT want to rent theirs.

For instance, you can do this if you live in Ohio and you’ll be renting a car while visiting New York.  That’s because Ohio and New York both use the E-Z pass toll system.  So remember to pack your transponder in your suitcase!

But say you live in Texas and you’ll be flying to Massachusetts and then renting a car to see the colorful autumn leaves in Vermont and the Northeast.  Because Texas has a different toll system, you’ll have to get the E-Z pass transponder.

Some Rental Car Companies Charge An Extra 15 Per Toll
E-Z Pass Is the Toll System of 15 States, Including Most of the Northeast

To get an E-Z pass device (the toll system of much of the Mid-Atlantic, Northeast, and Midwest) sign-up online and add at least the minimum $25 into your account.  This money will be used to pay future tolls.

The transponder will be mailed to your address within 5 to 10 business days.

Check the toll system of the states you’ll be driving through and make a plan!

For example, folks who will be renting a car in Florida can purchase the SunPass transponder at 1 of 2,000 locations including CVS, Publix (a large supermarket chain) and at Turnpike service centers.

Or you can order the SunPass transponder online for ~$5 plus the required $10 starting balance.  It will be mailed to you within 7 days.

So if you’re renting a car to use on toll roads in Florida for more than 1 day, you’ll probably save money buying your own SunPass.  That’s because according to the state, rental car companies charge anywhere between ~$4 per day (Alamo, Avis, Budget, Enterprise, National) to ~$9 (Dollar, Thrifty) to use their SunPass plus the cost of tolls.

Some Rental Car Companies Charge An Extra 15 Per Toll
You’ll Save ~30 Minutes Taking the Toll Roads From Universal Studios in Orlando to the Kennedy Space Center in Florida

When renting a car in Florida, you may find this page helpful.

Each state has different rules (and fees!) for getting a transponder.  Naturally you don’t want to pay more for a transponder than what the rental car company would charge you!

And some toll programs require to put an initial minimum balance on your transponder.  So if you won’t be using it much, you might be better off not getting one.  That said, you might qualify for a discount using your AAA membership.

Pay-by-Plate Might Be Easier

There are new programs making it easier to avoid purchasing a transponder by taking a photo of your license plate.  This is sometimes called Pay-by-Plate.  You cross the toll and then you’ll have a certain amount of time to pay your bill online.

For example, you can pay online in the San Francisco area here.  But it will cost you a bit more than using a transponder.

If you already have a transponder that works in the places you’ll be visiting, it’s an easy decision to bring it.   But if you’re consider purchasing 1, look carefully at the charges associated with it!

3 – Pay With Cash

This is certainly the easiest option!  But unfortunately, not all tollways accept cash anymore.  For example, parts of California and Florida do NOT accept cash.

For example, you can’t pay cash at a toll booth to drive over the Golden Gate Bride in San Francisco.

Some Rental Car Companies Charge An Extra 15 Per Toll
Toll Booths on the Golden Gate Bridge Are All Electronic With No Cash Option

Folks visiting Orange County, or driving from San Diego to Los Angeles, or driving from the Inland Empire or mountains to Orange County beaches, you may find this toll app helpful.  Because you might find it difficult to pay with cash!

When paying cash, keep in mind you’ll sometimes pay more.  For example, in New York, folks who pay cash are charged 5% more than those who use E-Z Pass.

Bottom Line

Many of the major car rental agencies charge you daily fees (usually ~$10) to rent their transponders.  And some charge you an additional ~$15 fee per toll!

To save money, you can tell the rental car company that you do NOT want their toll transponder.  Be sure you know exactly what you’ll be paying per day and per toll.

You can use your GPS or map program to skip toll roads.

Or if you already have a compatible transponder, bring it with you!  Otherwise, you can purchase a transponder for the states you’ll be traveling through.  When visiting Florida this is relatively easy.

But double-check the price and required toll balance to be sure it makes sense! Because each state has their own rules and fees.

You might try to pay cash instead.  But not all toll roads have cash lanes and sometimes the cash price is more expensive.

See my series on rental cars for more money saving tips!

Editorial Note: We're the Million Mile Secrets team. And we're proud of our content, opinions and analysis, and of our reader's comments. These haven’t been reviewed, approved or endorsed by any of the airlines, hotels, or credit card issuers which we often write about. And that’s just how we like it! :)

Join the Discussion!

1 Comment
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments