Mostly Disappointing Changes Coming to American Airlines Loyalty Program

Disclosure: We get a commission for links on the blog. You don’t have to use our links, but we’re very grateful when you do. American Express, Barclaycard, Chase, and US Bank are Million Mile Secrets advertising partners. Opinions expressed here are the author's alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or endorsed by our partners. Here’s our Advertiser Disclosure.

Folks who enjoy Big Travel With Small Money on American Airlines won’t be happy with many of the upcoming changes to the American Airlines loyalty program.

Via One Mile at a Time, there will be 5 major changes taking place in the next 2 to 6 months including:

  • Changes to complimentary upgrades
  • Executive Platinum award ticket upgrades
  • New elite status level
  • Revenue-based earning based on price of ticket
  • Spending requirement to earn elite status
Mostly Disappointing Changes Coming To American Airlines Loyalty Program

5 Major Changes Are Coming to the American Airlines Loyalty Program, Making It Harder to Earn Elite Status

Most of these changes will make it harder for folks to earn elite status with American Airlines.

I’ll explain more about the upcoming changes!

What’s the Story?

Link:   American Airlines Loyalty Program Updates

When American Airlines merged with US Airways in 2014, I wrote how the American Airlines loyalty program was staying (mostly) the same.  But things change quickly in this hobby!

Since then, American Airlines has modified many parts of their loyalty program, like changes to their award chart.

Mostly Disappointing Changes Coming To American Airlines Loyalty Program

After Adding a New Award Chart, American Airlines Will Be Making New Changes to Their Loyalty Program in the Upcoming Months

And now, there will be even more changes to the American Airlines loyalty program.  Here’s a summary of what to expect.

Revenue-Based Earning

Starting August 1, 2016, you’ll earn American Airlines miles based on the price of your ticket instead of distance traveled.  While this is not an unexpected change, we now know the official start date.

The more you spend on a flight and the higher your elite status, the more American Airlines miles you’ll earn.  For example, you’ll get:

  • 5 American Airlines miles per $1 for AAdvantage members
  • 7 American Airlines miles per $1 for Gold members
  • 8 American Airlines miles per $1 for Platinum members
  • 9 American Airlines miles per $1 for Platinum Pro members
  • 11 American Airlines miles per $1 for Executive Platinum members

If you book a partner airline flight through American Airlines, you’ll earn award miles based on a percentage of the flight distance and the fare class of your ticket.  Rates for partner airlines will be available on July 15, 2016.

This change makes the American Airlines loyalty program similar to Delta and United Airlines, which also have a revenue-based earning system.

If you’re a casual flyer who doesn’t mind flying long distances in coach, you’ll now earn fewer American Airlines miles with this new system.

For example, if you’re a AAdvantage member and book a round-trip coach fare for $800 from Dallas to London, you’d earn ~9,000 American Airlines miles under the current system.  But, after August 1, 2016, you’d earn only 4,000 American Airlines miles ($800 fare X 5 American Airlines miles per $1).  That’s a bummer!

New Platinum Pro Elite Status

American Airlines is adding a new elite status level called Platinum Pro.  To qualify, you’ll need a combination of

  • 75,000 elite-qualifying miles or 90 elite-qualifying segments AND
  • $9,000 elite-qualifying dollars in a calendar year

Benefits of Platinum Pro include:

  • Higher revenue-based earning of 9 American Airlines miles per $1 spent
  • Unlimited complimentary upgrades on flights within 500 miles

Spending Requirement to Earn Elite Status

Effective January 1, 2017, to earn American Airlines elite status, you’ll need to spend a certain amount in addition to having a certain number of elite-qualifying miles or elite-qualifying segments.

Here’s how much you have to spend to earn elite status at each level:

  • $3,000 for Gold
  • $6,000 for Platinum
  • $9,000 for Platinum Pro
  • $12,000 for Executive Platinum

Again, this change is NOT good for folks looking to earn elite status by booking cheap fares.

One unknown at this point is if American Airlines will lower the requirement for folks with American Airlines credit cards like the Citi® / AAdvantage® Executive World Elite(TM) MasterCard®.

Upgrade Changes

There will be 2 changes impacting American Airlines upgrades.

The major change is how American Airlines will prioritize your upgrade starting later in 2017.  Your upgrade will be determined on your elite status level AND the amount of money spent in the last 12 months.

The 2nd change is Executive Platinum members will be able to use their complimentary 500-mile upgrades on award tickets.

Bottom Line

In the upcoming months, American Airlines will make several changes to their loyalty program including revenue-based earning, new elite status, an elite status spending requirement, and upgrade changes.

Most of these changes are NOT good for folks looking to earn elite status without spending a lot of money.

What are your thoughts about the new policies?  Will you plan to keep your American Airlines elite status?

* If you liked this post, why don’t you join the 20,000+ readers who have signed-up to receive free blog posts via email (only 1 email per day!) or in an RSS reader …because then you’ll never miss another update!

Editorial Disclaimer: Neither the responses below nor the editorial content on this page are provided or commissioned by the bank advertisers, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertisers. Opinions expressed here are the author’s alone, not those of the bank advertisers. It is not the bank advertisers’ responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

11 responses to “Mostly Disappointing Changes Coming to American Airlines Loyalty Program

  1. Thank you for putting the fact of the matter in the title!!! Many sites I’ve read have sugar coated these changes. As a previous Executive Platinumwho earned status without excessive spending I’m really p/o’d with these changes. Sadly the alternatives are not any better. Domestic airlines in general are just racing to the bottom.

  2. Any ideas on what airline I should credit paid fares after this change?

  3. I just bought a ticket to Vietnam. Under the old system, I would have gotten 26,000. With the new system, I’ll get 7,483. This is terrible news. Bleh

  4. How do these changes affect old timers who earned Lifetime Gold and Platinum status in the ‘good ole days’ when even your cc sign up bonuses and purchases helped you reached lifetime status?

  5. Not good AA. Booooo!

  6. American (actually former USAirways) this is not a surprise. They are the least consumer friendly airline IMO. Years ago I had Silver status from achieving the requisite number of flights. Now, Silver status is nearly worthless. Not even worth trying. I’ve been a SWA A-list member for the past 2 years. Definitely a better program than any of the other domestic carriers. Ability to change flights w/o the ridiculous change fee. And earning the companion pass is not too difficult for a frequent flyer who also uses the SWA shopping mall.

  7. Although one earns redeemable miles according to their status, Do we still earn EQM s according to distance flown ?

  8. This is elitist crap. I used to choose American because of loyalty and the desire to earn miles with a single carrier. I don’t travel for business as often anymore but I do fly about 5-6 times a year on my own dime. Price matters.
    Looks like I’m switching. Between JAL, BA, and now AA the oneworld alliance is just crap.

  9. Counterpoint: airlines issuing fewer miles (by basing awards on revenue rather than miles flown) is a GOOD thing for those of us who primarily earn miles through credit card spend. Fewer miles issued = fewer people chasing award seats = more availability.

  10. As a current EP (plus United Premier 1K through matching) and small business owner, this means that I will have to review my membership in these programs very carefully as follows:
    1. Award miles for trips are irrelevant from my aspect – I truly would not notice if I earned only 5,000 award miles for a 1,000 mile trip rather than 11,000 miles… This mainly because many major business expenses go through credit cards – and especially the 5X categories for Chase Ultimate Rewards really generate a lot of points! (limited to 250,000 per year though) generate more than enough award travel miles/points…
    2. It has become more difficult over the past few years to maintain the elite/premier qualifying miles for each program. This is more an issue on AA. United allocates more PQMs based on status than actual miles flown. From an AA aspect, only the Aviator Silver and Aviator Executive Platinum still contribute (10k miles each after $40,000 spending) towards elite status. The Aviator (previously US Airways) Business card no longer provides that perk (so we have cancelled that business account!).
    As an aside, I am likely going to be able to maintain AA EP status this year and although I will probably achieve the PQMs for United, as a small business owner I cannot justify handing over $12k for exorbitantly priced seats just to maintain that status…

    For next year, reviewing my travel spending, it is apparent that the airlines are only concerned about income and have no interest in loyalty. (In fact that should rename them REVENUE programs), I may decide to retain membership, but not focus on any elite status. Based on this, instead of using frequent flyer miles/points for holiday travel, use them for business trips and continue to purchase the most cost-effective tickets available… Obviously at the end of 2017 I would lose the majority of my elite status (would probably retain Gold just based on the existing flight costs), but would have saved many thousands of dollars. Whilst the elite perks are nice, in reality they are not all that much… First class upgrades on domestic flights means a slightly larger seat, free drinks and a meal – I can do without that very easily.

    From an AA aspect, this would mean that I will be flying far less with them (there would be no incentive for me to book a slightly more expensive ticket for funding their REVENUE program). Unfortunately most of my travel is from East coast to Caribbean with occasional trips to Europe and Far East so alternative cheaper fares are not that easy to find, but certainly I will look at SouthWest and fly out of BWI rather than Philadelphia…

    Quite possibly this is what AA is looking to achiever? To get rid of the previously loyal, but cost-sensitive business traveler and only focus on the large corporate business traveler who are able to pay exorbitant business class airfares. This is now a very real possibility in my instance.

    And certainly if I no longer have much status with them, it will take a lot of convincing for me to try to reacquire that status in future – especially as low cost flights to Europe on Iceland Air and Norwegian are available….

    Maybe I am just a cheapskate to them – but currently one who is flying over 80,000 miles with them should mean something…?

  11. So, I’m trying to get an airline card for free miles redeemable for trips to Panama City, Panama, Dublin, Ireland, and/or London. American, Delta, and United seem to have similar offers. Are there other options (eg, British Airway or Starwood cards), different airlines, or better options? How else can I get “free” flights to these locations?
    Also, I note that even using one of these cards that finding reasonable flights (short duration and connections) using redeemable miles is next to impossible. Any suggestions?
    It seems like it’s almost better to NOT have an airline card because the miles aren’t easily usable – Use reward and/or hotel cards and pay for flights (still look for deals). True?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *