Citi Is Inviting Folks to Convert Their Cards. But Should You?

It'd mean a lot to Emily and me if y’all would take 10 seconds to vote for us as your favorite miles & points blog! Thank you!

P.S. You can vote every day. :)

Disclosure: We get a commission for links on the blog. You don’t have to use our links, but we’re very grateful when you do. American Express, Barclaycard, Chase, and US Bank are Million Mile Secrets advertising partners. Opinions expressed here are the author's alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or endorsed by our partners. Here’s our Advertiser Disclosure.

Update:   One or more card offers in this post are no longer available.  Check our Hot Deals for the latest offers. 

Update:   Beginning July 23, 2017, Citi ThankYou points with the Citi Prestige card will be worth 1.25 cents each toward flights. 

My friend recently received an email inviting him to switch his Citi Diamond Preferred card to the Citi ThankYou Preferred.

And he isn’t the only 1 who’s received an offer like this.  Citi is contacting certain cardholders about converting their cards.  For example, some folks who have the Citi Dividend card (no longer available) have been invited to switch to the Citi Double Cash.

Citi Is Inviting Folks To Convert Their Cards But Should You

Has Citi Offered to Switch You to Another Card?

I’ll help you decide if moving to a new card makes sense of you!

Should You Switch to a New Card?

A friend of my mind has the Citi Diamond Preferred card and Citi sent him an invitation to change to the Citi ThankYou Preferred.

Citi Is Inviting Folks To Convert Their Cards But Should You

If You Get an Offer Like This from Citi, You Can Change to a New Card With the Click of a Button. But Should You?

The Citi Easy Deals points you get with Citi Diamond Preferred card are lackluster.  You earn 10 Citi Easy Deals points for every $100 you spend on this card which can be redeemed for discounts at certain retailers.  But there are NO bonus categories and you can NOT redeem for paid travel or transfer for airline and hotel partners.

The best redemption he gets is 10% off at his favorite local Mexican restaurant.  While that does allow him to order extra guacamole, it’s hardly the Big Travel with Small Money he can earn with a card like the Citi ThankYou Preferred.

But in a moment I’ll explain why he might NOT want to take Citi up on their offer!

Here are some things you should consider before making a “product change” to a different card.

1.   The Bank Doesn’t Need a Credit Check

When you make a product change (convert a card to a different card), the bank moves your current line of credit over to the new card.  So you won’t have to compete a new application.  And the bank does NOT pull your credit report.

A hard credit pull can lower your score ~3 to ~5 points.  The impact begins to drop off after ~6 months.  But banks don’t like to see too many inquiries on your credit report because it could mean you’re less likely to pay your debt.

Citi Is Inviting Folks To Convert Their Cards But Should You

You Can Avoid a Hard Credit Pull by Having the Bank Move You to Another Card

By switching to a new card instead of completing a new application, you can save the hard pull for another card with a sign-up bonus.

2.   You Won’t Earn the Sign-Up Bonus

Because the bank will move your current account to the new card, you won’t be considered a new cardholder.  And you will NOT be eligible to earn the sign-up bonus.

Citi Is Inviting Folks To Convert Their Cards But Should You

Credit Card Sign-Up Bonuses Are the Fastest Way to Earn Big Travel! If You Convert to Another Card Without Completing a New Application, You’ll Miss Out on the Bonus

If you complete a new application for the Citi ThankYou Preferred, you’ll earn 20,000 Citi ThankYou points when you spend $1,500 on purchases within the 1st 3 months of opening your account.

You can redeem the 20,000 Citi ThankYou points you earn for:

So my friend won’t convert his card to the Citi ThankYou Preferredbecause he might want to earn the bonus some time down the road.

3.   Would This Be an Upgrade?

Had your eye on another card that doesn’t offer a sign-up bonus, but has other interesting benefits?  You can switch to a card that works better for you.

So instead, my friend might request a product change to the Citi Double Cash.  With this card he can earn 1% cash back on all purchases and 1% cash back on all payments.  There’s no annual fee and he won’t be missing out on a sign-up bonus, because it doesn’t offer one.

Citi Is Inviting Folks To Convert Their Cards But Should You

When the Bank Changes You to a New Card, You Get to Keep Your Account History, Which Makes Up 15% of Your Credit Score

This is a good move, especially if the Citi Diamond Preferred card is 1 of his oldest cards.  It’s important to hang onto your oldest cards because the length of your credit history makes up 15% of your credit score and it helps you build a long-term relationship with the bank.

So in this case, he gets to keep his credit history with Citi and upgrade to a card that will give him better rewards for his spending.

For folks who have the Citi Dividend card (no longer available) and received an offer to switch to the Citi Double Cash card, the best card for you depends on your spending habits.

With the Citi Dividend card, you can earn up to $300 in cash back per year in rotating 5% cash back categories.  You’d have to spend ~$15,000 on your Citi Double Cash ($15,000 X ~2% cash back) to earn ~$300 in cash back.

If you are doing that much spending, you might want to consider using it to unlock sign-up bonuses on lucrative travel cards, like the Chase Sapphire Preferred, Citi Prestige, or the Barclaycard Arrival Plus instead.

But if you don’t plan to spend too much in the Citi Dividend’s 5% categories, the Citi Double Cash card might be a more convenient option.  That’s because you won’t have to worry about spending in specific categories to earn bonus cash back.

Bottom Line

Have you received an offer from Citi or another bank to switch to a new card?

This could give you the ability to get a new card without another credit inquiry.  But keep in mind, you will NOT be eligible to earn the sign-up bonus, which is the #1 way to earn Big Travel with Small Money.

So it may only be worth the change if it’s a card that doesn’t offer a sign-up bonus.  Also, do the math to see if you’d earn more miles, points, or cash back with the new card based on your spending habits.

* If you liked this post, why don’t you join the 25,000+ readers who have signed-up to receive free blog posts via email (only 1 email per day!) or in an RSS reader …because then you’ll never miss another update!

Editorial Disclaimer: Neither the responses below nor the editorial content on this page are provided or commissioned by the bank advertisers, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertisers. Opinions expressed here are the author’s alone, not those of the bank advertisers. It is not the bank advertisers’ responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4 responses to “Citi Is Inviting Folks to Convert Their Cards. But Should You?

  1. I got an invitation from Citi to convert my Dividend to TY Preferred. I don’t spend anything on my Dividend card since I am always using my CSP, SPG, and Citi TY Premier. It does seem like Double Cash would be a better way to go, since it seems to be lacking in the bonus offers arena. It is kind of nice having a World Elite card, and if I converted to Preferred it would just be a World. One thing that really has made me hesitate is, according to the email from Cit, “best of all, (I) get to keep the same account number after (I) convert!” Really? That is the best part?

  2. I usr citi dividend card for balance transfers. My concern is, if i switch will i still be getting balance transfer offers??

  3. Received the email, and today a letter in the mail, offering me the option to “upgrade” to the Thank You Preferred.

    I”m holding on to the Dividend card for the 5% categories. I already have cards that earn 2% on dining and entertainment…

  4. I got one of these offers and my current card (AT&T Universal Card) has absolutely no benefits I use. I’ve been with them for 18 years. I don’t want to lose the length of credit history. According to this blogger, “upgrading” to a different product brings the credit history over to the new card. I can’t find info on this offer or on the offer online that specifically says my credit history will be moved with it. Do you believe this blog to be true?